The Alco RS11
The RS11 began a new class of road switcher for Alco. The model was the first offered with a low, short hood and
came equipped with the manufacturer's newest prime mover.
Unfortunately, it could not recapture the market from similar
designs soon offered by Electro-Motive. The model was
designed to compete directly with the GP9 although EMD's GP18, GP20, and
GP30 all entered production when the RS11 was still being cataloged by
Alco. By the time the RS11 debuted EMD was so backlogged with
orders for the GP9, along with the fact that railroads had become
somewhat distrustful of Alco due to its problematic prime movers, the model had little chance to offer strong competition. Despite these issues the RS11 proved to be Alco's best
selling late model Road Switcher (RS) design. Today, several examples remain preserved.
|Buffalo Southern RS11 #5010 lays over in Eden, New York on May 26, 2002. The Alco began service on the Delaware & Hudson in May of 1961 carrying the same number.|
was seemingly always racing to catch EMD in an attempt to
remain competitive with the industry's leading locomotive manufacturer.
Ironically, it had pioneered the road switcher design with its initial RS1 in 1941. However, by the time EMD released the GP9 in 1954
Alco had fallen far behind in the market as the General Motors company was simply offering far superior products that were more rugged, reliable, and efficient. In 1956 the Schenectady builder released the RS11 model, listed by Alco as its DL701. In many ways, perhaps the RS11
best described Alco's losing battle against EMD, and very soon against
General Electric as well. Of course, releasing the model when it did nearly two years after the GP9 went
on sale Alco was once again trying to catch up.
Some of its sales for the RS11 was the result of EMD being so backlogged with
orders for the GP9 that some railroads went elsewhere to fill their locomotive shortage. Interestingly, Alco's product in this case was actually a
better locomotive than the GP9 in terms of specifications: whereas the
GP9 featured 1,750 horsepower the RS11, using Alco's new model 251B engine,
could produce 1,800 horsepower; it offered a continuous tractive
effort rating of 47,000 pounds compared to the GP9's 40,000 pounds; and
finally the model could accelerate faster while spending less fuel
than the GP9 thanks to its 12-cylinder prime mover (EMD's 567C used 16 cylinders). This last feature was a trademark of Alco engineering but unfortunately was not a considerable sales advantage in those days.
|Duluth, Winnipeg & Pacific RS11 #3607 sits next to the turntable in Duluth, Minnesota on August 22, 1966.|
Despite these improvements the RS11 really never offered serious
competition for EMD, despite Alco's best attempts. The new 251B prime mover did, at least, give railroads more reason to
trust the builder's reliability as the engine was not nearly as trouble-prone as
the earlier model 244. For the first time Alco began giving railroads
the option to purchase road switchers with either low or high, short
hoods (it was always an option before, but only via special request).
Still, most continued to purchase them with high hoods although some
like the Delaware & Hudson and Southern Pacific did order a few with
Beginning with the RSD7, Alco changed the appearance of its road switcher, making it truly a Schenectady
product. The builder's RS1s, RS2s, RS3s, and their variants all
featured cabs protruding well above both long and short hoods. However,
Alco changed its design so as the hood (particularly the long hood)
mounted flush with the top of the cab. While radiator housings, vents,
and other minor various exterior elements could denote an EMD from Alco
perhaps what truly set the latter apart was the notched corners housing number boards. This very small, yet classy touch makes for an easy spotting feature of Alco locomotives.
Production Roster Of Alco RS11s
|Carolina & North-Western||11||1||1956|
|Delaware & Hudson||5000-5011||12||1960-1961|
|Duluth, Winnipeg & Pacific||3600-3614||15||1956|
|Green Bay & Western||309||1||1956|
|Monongahela Connecting Railroad||700||1||1957|
|New York Central||8000-8008||9||1957|
|Nickel Plate Road||558-577, 850-864||35||1956-1960|
|Norfolk & Western||308-406||99||1956-1961|
|Seaboard Air Line||100-109||10||1960|
|Southern Pacific||5723-5729, 5845-5871||34||1956-1959|
|Toledo, Peoria & Western||400-402||3||1958-1959|
|Southern Pacific RS11 #5858 sits with GP9 #5780, sporting the road's "Black Widow" livery, next to the Phoenix, Arizona roundhouse on July 24, 1962.|