In any event, the EP5s proved their worth and were quite adept in
passenger and commuter service on the NYNH&H. However, due to their
high price tag, and the fact that by the 1950s the railroad was in
serious financial trouble (it would later file for bankruptcy
in the early 1960s) the NYNH&H only purchased ten units of the EP5.
Instead, the railroad found that the duel-mode FL9s from EMD proved to
be just as effective and much cheaper to purchase (not to mention that
they could operate using both electricity and diesel as a primary fuel source).
While the locomotives were quite reliable, quick accelerating,
and very fast they did have some issues. Most notable was their
overheating issue when in cramped places, such as tunnels and station
approaches, where the loud and noisy blowers (a reason they received the
name, "Jets") could not intake enough fresh air to keep the units cool.
Usually, this was not an issue although after one EP5 caught fire
after the creation of Penn Central they were banned from use in New
In the end, the EP5s only saw about ten years of use under New
Haven before the railroad was forced into the Penn Central debacle in
1968, where the locomotives were reassigned as E-40s and remained in
commuter service, save for two which were retrofitted for freight duty.
Even before the PC takeover the NYNH&H had begun to park the units
in favor to the cheaper FL9s. In the very late years of the New Haven
the railroad lost interest in much of its electrified operations. While
the FL9s were cheaper to purchase the EP5s were cheaper to operate and
resulted in long-term savings. After the Penn Central took over the six
now E-40s saw regular use until the 1973 fire incident in New York
City's Park Avenue Tunnel, which resulted in the entire fleet being
pulled from service.
Incidentally, Amtrak two years earlier decided against using them along the Northeast Corridor and they sat in storage until Conrail took over PC's operations in the spring of 1976. Conrail kept the fleet on its early roster, as the carrier did employ electric operations for its freight services
very early on. However, none ultimately operated under Conrail and
were sent to the scrapper in 1979. Today, sadly, no EP5s remain
|A closeup view of New Haven EP5 #375 heading southbound for Grand Central Terminal near New Rochelle with a commuter consist during February of 1969.|