Shortlines, Where Customer Service Is Key!

Shortlines, whose designation by the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) is a Class III carrier (terminal and switching railroads also are included under the Class III status), by far make up the bulk of railroads in the country today, totaling some 500. The Association of American Railroads (AAR) defines these systems as any railroad earning less than $10 million of annual operating revenue.  While Class IIIs are by far the smallest in the industry in both terms of miles of track (some are as short as one mile or less, such as the Little Kanawha Railroad located in Parkersburg, West Virginia) and money earned, they usually are the most interesting. For instance if you have an interest in classic diesels they abound onthese railroads . Anything from little switchers like General Electric (GE) 44-tonners and American Locomotive Company (Alco) S-1s, built in the 1930s and 1940s, to General Motors’ EMD line of GP7s (GP models are commonly known as “Geeps” by railroaders and railfans) and SD9s (built later in the 1950s). All of these, plus many other types and from many other long-gone manufacturers, can still be found on these little railroads racking up the miles.

Meandering along through the bucolic scenery of northern Virginia Winchester & Western's Sandman freight rolls through Hayfield during a summer day in 2003.

What Class IIIs lack in size they more than make up for in services they provide their customers, a trait which they are best known for.  The railroads literally live or die by the sometimes few precious carloads they are able to haul each year and cannot afford to give up a customer or two to make their bottom-line numbers look better (as is sometimes the case with their much large cousins, Class Is and large Regionals, although Regionals are also known for their very good customer service). Some are even in operation because of only one customer they serve, and if that customer happens to leave for whatever reason then the railroad must either close down or enter a dormant state while waiting for a new customer(s) to appear.

A good example of this would be the Elk River Railroad in Gassaway, West Virginia which was originally created in 1989 to haul coal from a new mine that had recently opened but after it closed ten years later in 1999, the railroad has sat basically dormant since that time and today occasionally handles car-repair work. Of course, on the other end of the spectrum are large shortlines that operate several hundred miles of track and are nearly Class IIs. These include names like RJ Corman, Iowa Northern Railway, Livonia, Avon & Lakeville, and others. For historical sake there also those companies which have been in operation for more than 100 years such as the Indiana Harbor Belt, St. Marys Railroad, Ann Arbor, and others. The bottom line is that you can find Class IIIs of all shapes and sizes around the country.

Two Montana Rail Link SD40-2s and an F45XR perform switching duties at the yard in F45XR at Garrison, Montana during 2004.

This grittiness in the face of adversity is another reason these railroads have a uniqueness that is all their own and sometimes their very being keeps a rail line from abandonment, not to mention the help they provide their local economy (far too often rail lines are abandoned and left for dead when they could still be serving a purpose and helping the economy in which they are located). Even today, new Class III railroads continue to spring up like the once-dormant, historic Grafton & Upton Railroad in Massachusetts which has sprung to life and the new owner has a vast array of new plans for the company. Of course, not all are privately owned as you may think. Just like the classic, fallen flag lines many are being gobbled up by large conglomerates such as Genesee & Wyoming, Watco Companies, and a number of others.

Northeast

Arcade & Attica

Grafton & Upton

Little Kanawha River Railroad

Livonia, Avon & Lakeville

South Branch Valley

West Virginia Central

Morristown & Erie

Middletown & Hummelstown

New Hope & Ivyland

Winchester & Western

Southeast

Aberdeen & Rockfish

Aberdeen, Carolina & Western

Apalachicola Northern

Atlanta & St. Andrews Bay

Columbus & Greenville

De Queen & Eastern

South Carolina Central

Georgia Northeastern

Georgia Southwestern

Pickens Railway

Chesapeake & Albemarle

Lancaster & Chester

Louisiana & North West

Pinsly Company

Sandersville Railroad

St. Marys Railroad

Meridian & Bigbee

Arizona & California SD40 #708 travels along through the open Mojave Desert at Cadiz, California as it trundles over a small trestle during 2005.

Midwest

Ann Arbor Railroad

Arkansas & Missouri

Belt Railway of Chicago

Cedar Rapids & Iowa City

Chicago, SouthShore & South Bend

Escanaba & Lake Superior

Indiana Harbor Belt

Iowa Traction

Lake Superior & Ishpeming

RJ Corman Railroad Group

Indiana & Ohio

Ohio Central

Alton & Southern

Iowa Northern

Toledo, Peoria & Western

Illinois & Midland

Sand Springs Railway

Tulsa-Sapulpa Union

Terminal Railroad Association Of St. Louis

The historic Aberdeen & Rockfish has been operating in North Carolina since 1892. Seen here is a westbound freight at Dundarrach, North Carolina led by GP38 #400 and GP7 #205 during early 2004.

Southwest

Black Mesa & Lake Powell

Sierra Railroad

Arizona & California

Fort Worth & Western

Apache Railway

Dallas, Garland & Northeastern

Farmrail

Copper Basin Railway

Pecos Valley Southern

Trona Railway

Modesto & Empire Traction Company

Northwest

Butte, Anaconda & Pacific

Port of Tillamook Bay

Idaho, Northern & Pacific

St. Maries River Railroad

Utah Railway

Eastern Idaho Railroad

Red River Valley & Western

Twin Cities & Western

Defunct Lines

Ashley, Drew & Northern

Camas Prairie Railroad

Chesapeake Western

Copper Range Railroad

Durham & Southern

East Tennessee & Western North Carolina, The "Tweetsie"

Erie Western

Frankfort & Cincinnati

Lake Erie, Franklin & Clarion

Magma Arizona

McCloud River

Montour Railroad

North Louisiana & Gulf

Pittsburg & Shawmut

Quanah, Acme & Pacific Railway, "The Quanah Route"

Rahway Valley

Reader Railroad

Roscoe, Snyder & Pacific

St. Johnsbury & Lamoille County

Texas Mexican

Toronto, Hamilton & Buffalo

Wellsville, Addison & Galeton

West Virginia Northern

While these lines continue to keep their names, liveries and management is replaced by the new owners. Also, while the shortline phenomenon is a relatively new trend only 30 years old or so, at least in the sense that it has become quite popular with the large Class Is selling off hundreds of miles of secondary lines there are historic companies that no longer operate. These include names like the Maryland & Pennsylvania ("Ma & Pa"), Virginia & Truckee, and others. Lastly, for more information on a number of the Class IIIs which operate throughout the country please click on their appropriate link listed above.


Fort Worth & Western GP50 #2011, better known as Miss Etta, sits at at the yard in Cresson, Texas with several other Geeps during the summer of 2007.

So, if you get the chance and know of a local system in your area be sure and see it in action if the opportunity presents itself (many only operate on certain days of the week). While watching a Class I container train moving at 60+ mph across the Heartland is always thrilling, nothing can likewise beat observing a local line switching its customer(s) and moving those cars between there, the interchange point (where smaller roads swap loaded and empty cars with the big Class Is), and back again. If you want to see the human side of railroading, no one does it better than these small lines. To learn more about them please click here to visit the American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association's (ASLRRA) website. This member organization is similar in nature to the Association of American Railroads but geared towards smaller, non-Class I carriers. Finally, here is a guide to most shore lines operating around the country.

Share Your Thoughts

Have your say about what you just read! Leave me a comment in the box below. Please note that while I strive to present the information as accurately as possible I am aware that there may be errors. If you have potential corrections the help is greatly appreciated.

Check out the website's digital book (E-book), An Atlas To Classic Short Lines, which features system maps and a brief background of 46 different historic railroads.



Related Reading

Notable Short Lines



Aberdeen, Carolina & Western




Aberdeen & Rockfish




Apache Railway




Arkansas & Missouri




Atlanta & St. Andrews Bay




Belt Railway Of Chicago




De Queen & Eastern




Farmrail




Fort Worth & Western




Grafton & Upton




Indiana Harbor Belt




Iowa Northern




Iowa Traction




Lancaster & Chester




Livonia, Avon & Lakeville




Louisiana & North West




Meridian & Bigbee




Pickens Railway




RJ Corman




Sandersville Railroad




Terminal Railroad Association Of St. Louis




Twin Cities & Western




Utah Railway




Winchester & Western

Popular Reading



Fallen Flags




Industry History




Class Is




Class II, Regionals




Amtrak




Freight Equipment

Upcoming/Notable Events



Thomas The Train




Streamliners At Spencer




The "Big Boy" #4014 Project




Norfolk Southern's "Heritage Program"




Fall Foliage Excursions, Where To Ride




"The Polar Express" Excursions, Dates And Locations