The streamliner craze that was so prevalent during the 1930s had slowed down by the late 1940s, although train travel remained a popular mode of transportation for most during the decade. However, following WWII and into the 1950s railroads watched helplessly as passenger traffic plummeted and not even new equipment and promotional advertising could sway passengers back to the rails. Some lines continued to spend money on new streamliners, such as the Pennsylvania Railroad, for passengers that never came. The railroad industry after the 1940s also saw a slow decline in freight traffic, particularly less-than-carload (LCL) as the new interstate highway system began to take its toll.
After the end of the war one of the first tasks set forth by many railroads was to retire the iconic steam locomotive as fast as they could. From a macro view, the 1950's was not good for the industry; aside from declining passenger business, a recession and improved highways (including signage of the Interstate Highway Act) heavily eroded the industry's traffic. The situation would not improve until the Staggers Act was passed in 1980, greatly deregulating the industry.
The efficiency of diesel locomotives could not be argued and most lines had completed the switch by the mid-'50s while all Class Is had abandoned steam by 1960. It would take the diesel-electric locomotive nearly fifty years to equal the horsepower output of the steam locomotive during its technological height. However, diesels offered an advantage that far surpassed steamers and it was the deciding factor in them becoming the prime choice of motive power, efficiency. Diesels required far less maintenance in terms of overhauls (scheduled time in the shops for routine maintenance) and refueling (no longer were there frequent stops requiring water and coal/oil), which allowed them to be spending much more time moving freight and paying the bills.
While diesels may have helped the industry save millions in locomotive maintenance the same could not be said for passenger operations. With the explosion of traffic during the war and only a minor drop off through the end of the 1940s many railroads expected passengers to remain true to the railroads during the 1950s, which, unfortunately did not happen. Some lines spent lavishly on new equipment like the New York Central ($56 million in 1946) and the Pennsylvania Railroad ($3 million in 1952).
With President Dwight Eisenhower enacting the Interstate Highway System in 1956 (also known as the National Interstate and Defense Highways Act) and better highways and roads being built throughout the decade folks began to abandon trains for personal automobiles. Before the automobile came into existence railroads owned almost 100% of passenger traffic in the country but by 1957 held just 31.4%. A few stats regarding the decline of passenger railroading during these years:
Between an 18-year span following the year after World War II, 1946, passenger traffic declined from 770 million to 298 million by 1964.
By the '50s total industry losses on passenger rail service was over $700 million.
Commuter trains declined by 80% from over 2,500 in the mid-'50s to under 500 by the late 1960s.
Despite these setbacks railroads of the era did have some notable gains. For instance, ton-mileage per railroad worker had doubled every fifteen years since the end of World War I. Also, the 1950s saw an introduction of a new type of service, TOFC or trailer-on-flat-car. This service allowed railroads to haul unit trains of truck trailers, which was extremely efficient and beneficial to both industries and remains a highly lucrative service today. What began as an experiment in 1953 (one of the first lines to do so was the Chicago Great Western Railway) saw fifty railroads trying or testing TOFC service by 1959. And, track upgrades allowed for faster and heavier trains as mechanical machines began replacing track gangs, and rail of over 100 pounds covered more than half of all lines in operation by late in the decade.
The '50s also saw the beginning of the mega-merger movement with one of the first being the Norfolk & Western Railway's purchase of the Virginian Railway in 1959. While consolidations are a natural part of capitalism and the free market mergers began to increase in number by the middle of the decade partly because of the railroad industry's loss of market share to highways and airplanes. For instance, the overbuilt Northeast was probably the hardest hit by this market share setback. The Northeast's collapse culminated with the Penn Central bankruptcy of 1970 but it all likely started in 1951 when one Northeastern line, the Lehigh Valley Railroad, showed its final profits.
While the industry by the '50s was becoming more efficient it unfortunately did not stem the tide of losses, which only became worse a decade later. The decade saw many railroads in financial trouble as well as a number of mergers. Names like the mighty Pennsylvania Railroad, New York Central, Chicago Great Western, Erie, Lackawanna, Seabord Air Line, Atlantic Coast Line Railroad, and others would all disappear into merger in the 1960s. Also, passenger rail services began to worsen as lines cut back on spending as folks continued to abandon trains for cars and airplanes. By 1970 only the most popular named trains like the Empire Builder and Super Chief still carried full service, including sleepers.