B&O's Cincinnatian

Last revised: August 12, 2022

By: Adam Burns

One of the Baltimore & Ohio’s most exotic passenger trains was a regional dayliner, the Cincinnatian.  

This original version of this train featured 4-6-2's and equipment shrouded in streamlining by the company's own shop forces in Mount Clare and it served an unsustainable market between Washington, D.C. - Cincinnati, Ohio. 

It is rather interesting B&O officials chose this initial routing; while it operated the railroad's important St. Louis main line, there simply was not enough business between the terminating cities.

The largest markets between along the route included Cumberland (38,000), Grafton (7,300), Clarksburg (31,000), Parkersburg (30,000), and Athens (10,000). 

Nevertheless, the railroad spent a great deal of money, resources, and effort publicizing the train. 

Unfortunately, it proved unsuccessful.  As a result, the train was switched to the more populated Cincinnati - Detroit market. 

The Cincinnatian, while never terribly profitable, remained on the timetable for nearly 25 years and survived until the start of Amtrak in May, 1971.

Photos

One of Baltimore & Ohio's beautifully streamlined P-7d's (4-6-2) has train #76, the eastbound "Cincinnatian," crossing Tray Run Viaduct, circa 1949. Photographer unknown.

History

The Baltimore & Ohio, commonly known as the B&O, holds distinction as the country’s first common-carrier railroad, originally chartered on February 28, 1827 

As such, it was instrumental in building and growing the nation's economy and settling territory along the frontier when the "West" meant the Ohio River. 

Despite its marginal financial situation, the B&O holds many "firsts."  Some of these include:

  • It tested the first American-built steam locomotive, the Tom Thumb, in 1830.

  • It, along with the Santa Fe, was the first to employ a streamlined diesel in service, the EA of 1937.
  • It was first to offer air-conditioning on its trains.

  • It was the first to operate electric locomotives through its Howard Street tunnel in Baltimore).

  • It was the first to employ dome cars in the east.

The Cincinnatian was essentially a truncated, coach-only version of the B&O's premier National Limited, which linked New York City via Jersey Central's Communipaw Terminal at Jersey City, New Jersey) and St. Louis.

Within the pecking order of service along this route, it could be described as sitting in third behind the Diplomat, which complemented the National Limited.

Consist, 1948 (Washington - Cincinnati)

Perhaps B&O officials were caught up in streamliner mania sweeping the nation but the Washington-Cincinnati market was an odd choice to launch a dedicated service. 

The cities along the Cincinnatian's route included small communities like Martinsburg, Clarksburg, and Parkersburg, West Virginia and Athens and Chillicothe in Ohio.

Aside from Cumberland, the city on the run was Parkersburg, with a population at the time of just under 50,000 residents.

Timetable, 1947 (Washington - Cincinnati)

Time/Leave (Train #75) Location Time/Arrive (Train #76)
8:00 AM
Baltimore (Mt. Royal Station)
9:15 PM
8:05 AM
Baltimore (Camden Station)
9:08 PM
9:00 AM
Washington, D.C. (Union Station)
8:15 PM
9:13 AM
Silver Spring, MD
8:00 PM
10:23 AM
Martinsburg, WV
6:51 PM (Dp)
12:03 PM
Keyser, WV
5:12 PM (Dp)
2:18 PM
Grafton, WV
2:58 PM (Dp)
2:53 PM
Clarksburg, WV
2:20 PM (Dp)
4:45 PM
Parkersburg, WV
12:30 PM (Dp)
5:27 PM
Athens, OH
11:45 AM (Dp)
6:33 PM
Chillicothe, OH
10:39 AM (Dp)
8:07 PM (Ar)
Oakley, OH
9:04 AM (Dp)
8:16 PM (Ar)
Winton Place, OH
8:55 AM (Dp)
8:30 PM (Ar)
Cincinnati (Union Terminal)
8:45 AM (Dp)

The train debuted on January 19, 1947 and wasn't long before the railroad recognized the patronage problem. 

After just three years on its original schedule, the B&O switched the Cincinnatian to the Detroit - Cincinnati market in June of 1950.

Baltimore & Ohio E9A #1455 has train #53, the southbound "Cincinnatian," stopped at Dayton Union Station in 1971. American-Rails.com collection.

The Cincinnatian had been built entirely from heavyweight equipment.  However, one would never have known this at first glance as the B&O’s Mount Clare shop forces did a superb job of turning old cars into something quite beautiful. 

The consist was built completely from the ground up and arguably as finely crafted as anything constructed by Budd, Pullman-Standard, or American Car & Foundry.

Consist, 1952 (Cincinnati - Detroit)

The train was clad in a two-tone version of the B&O’s regal dark blue and accentuated with silver trim.  The livery was a version of the railroad's standard blue and grey passenger scheme.

The Cincinnatian's streamlining was the work of the B&O's own Olive Dennis, a female engineer. 

Even the lead locomotives were bedecked in match paint with similar streamlining; they certainly could not be missed!

Timetable, 1969 (Cincinnati - Detroit)

Time/Leave (Train #53) Milepost Location Time/Arrive (Train #54)
11:00 AM0
Detroit (C&O Railway, Fort Street Station)
5:40 PM
11:35 AM25
Plymouth, MI
4:54 PM
12:55 PM (Ar) 1:05 PM (Dp)82
Toledo, OH
3:45 PM (Dp) 3:30 (Ar)
1:47 PM (Ar) 2:05 PM (Dp)119
Deshler, OH
2:30 PM (Dp) 2:10 (Ar)
2:58 PM153
Lima, OH
1:16 PM
3:16 PM166
Wapakoneta, OH
12:59 PM
3:45 PM186
Sidney, OH
12:39 PM
3:58 PM196
Piqua, OH
12:18 PM
4:10 PM204
Troy, OH
12:07 PM
4:37 PM (Ar) 4:47 PM (Dp)224
Dayton, OH
11:40 AM (Dp) 11:25 (Ar)
5:11 PM246
Middletown, OH
11:02 AM
5:29 PM258
Hamilton, OH
10:47 AM
6:20 PM282
Cincinnati (Union Terminal)
10:00 AM

The Baltimore & Ohio's original "Cincinnatian" (Baltimore - Cincinnati), is seen here at an unknown location led by one of the road's handsome P-7d Pacific's (#5301-5304), circa 1947. The train's accommodations included a Coffee Shoppe Car, reclining seat coaches, and diner-lounge-observation. Poor ridership along the lightly-populated route resulted in the "Cincy" switching to a Cincinnati - Detroit schedule in June of 1950. Photographer unknown.

Final Years

The steamers were part of the B&O's handsome Class P-7d's and four, in all, #5301-5304 received the custom streamlining.

To complete the train's look it was given silver pinstriping with "The Cincinnatian" flanking the rear observation car.  On the Cincinnati – Detroit run, the train was renumbered as #53 southbound and #54 northbound.

Right up until the end the Cincinnatian continued providing beverage and food service between Cincinnati and Lima, Ohio along with reclining-seat coaches. 

  1. Home
  2.  ›
  3. Fallen Flags
  4.  ›
  5. Baltimore & Ohio
  6.  ›
  7. Cincinnatian

Recent Articles

  1. Pacific Great Eastern Railway

    Oct 02, 22 12:20 PM

    The Pacific Great Eastern, which became the British Columbia Railway after 1972, was the third largest system in Canada. CN acquired the property in 2004.

    Read More

  2. N&W 2-6-6-4 (Class A) Locomotives

    Oct 02, 22 11:53 AM

    Norfolk & Western's famous Class A 2-6-6-4's were simple expansion designs built during the late steam era. They moved freight and passengers until the 1950s.

    Read More

  3. 2-6-6-4 Steam Locomotives

    Oct 02, 22 11:06 AM

    The 2-6-6-4 was a late era steam design, one of the finest ever built. Four railroads operated them, most notable of which was the N&W's Class A fleet.

    Read More

  4. Northern Alberta Railways

    Oct 02, 22 10:52 AM

    The Northern Alberta Railways was a consolidated system, once jointly owned by CN and CP, that served its home territory. It disappeared into CN in 1981.

    Read More

  5. Yakima Valley Transportation

    Oct 01, 22 08:38 PM

    The Yakima Valley Transportation Company began life in 1906 as an interurban serving its namesake city in Washington. Because of its profitable freight business it was purchased by UP in the 1950s.

    Read More


SteamLocomotive.com

Wes Barris's SteamLocomotive.com is simply the best web resource on the study of steam locomotives. 

It is difficult to truly articulate just how much material can be found at this website. 

It is quite staggering and a must visit!