Observation Car (Trains)

Observation cars became a fixture on passenger trains with the development of the heavyweight passenger cars in the early 20th century (these heavyweight versions became very famous for use by presidents or presidential candidates when they used to campaign heavily by train). These early observations featured rear-end platforms (porches) with overhanging roofs.  At this time they served primarily two purposes; one, of course, was to allow passengers to enjoy the views from essentially a moving porch.  The other was to provide a "finished" appearance to the train and offer a location for its drumhead (name/logo).  However, it wasn't until the streamliner era that the observation is best remembered. With the development of lightweight, streamlined equipment, observations completed the look with almost all designs featuring a type of rounded end. 

Today, Amtrak has abandoned the use of observation cars although you can still ride aboard one by visiting one of the tourist railroads around the country which operate them.  In addition, a number of affluent individuals have restored both open-ended and streamlined observations for private use.  

Folks tour the brand new "La Mirada," (2-double bedroom, 1-drawing room sleeper/buffet-lounge-observation) built by Pullman-Standard in August of 1948 for the still-born "Golden Rocket," a joint Rock Island/Southern Pacific postwar transcontinental streamliner. It later found work on the "Golden State."

As John White, Jr. notes in his book, "The American Railroad Passenger Car (Part 1)," the earliest known examples of open-air observations appeared on private or office cars in the 1850's.  In 1869 the idea was pitched to George Pullman by Joseph Becker, an artist employed by Leslie's magazine, it does not appear Pullman showed much interest at this time.  These early observations are first known to appear in standard service with the 1888 debut of Pullman's Aladdin, an observation-lounge which appear that year on Union and Central Pacific's (Southern Pacific) Golden Gate Special.   In 1889 Pullman released an improved car, the Sybaris, which featured a roomier porch area.  After the release of these cars, observations became a fixture on the industry's top trains through the Great Depression era.  They even offered nighttime viewing in 1926 when Northern Pacific debuted a fleet of observation-clubs that included a 250-watt searchlight on the roof. 

The elegance of one of Illinois Central's observation-lounges (either the "Gulfport" or "Memphis," manufactured by Pullman in 1942) is still vividly on display in this scene captured by Roger Puta aboard the "Panama Limited" in May, 1964.

By the 1930's interest was waning in the open-air observation; when the train was at-speed they were windy, somewhat noisy, and kicked up a great deal of dust and dirt. This decade also saw the introduction of lightweight streamlining; coupled with the Art Deco era and more liberal use of colors, trains radically changed from dull modes of transportation to vibrant, fast, and flashy fixtures of Americana.  The close-ended observation first appeared in 1909 when the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy introduced sun parlor or solarium cars, which essentially featured large windows towards the rear and a location for the drumhead, which could be attached to either side of the end vestibule.  While it solved the open-air problem it did suffer from limited viewing.  With style all the rage, Pullman unveiled the so-called "swallow tail" car for the 1933 World's Fair.  It was constructed of aluminum and featured the now-classic round-end, a trademark of the streamlined era.

Not all modern observations were built with the round-end, as seen here with Delaware, Lackawanna & Western car #790, the "Tavern Lounge" used on the "Phoebe Snow." In truth, railroads actually came to favor the blunt-end car since they could operate at any point within a train, unlike the so-called "swallow tails," which could only be placed at the end. As a result, they required an additional switching move. The trade-off, of course, was the outward appearance.

Ironically, the idea was not original to Pullman.  It had actually first been tested around 1900 by F.U. Adams using a set of former Baltimore & Ohio wooden cars.  The final was product was nearly identical to what Pullman introduced over 30 years later.  Unfortunately, railroads came to recognize a major flaw with these cars; despite their good looks, they were a headache in general service.  Without an end vestibule they required an additional switching move and because of their shape, always had to be placed at the rear of a train; while this seems elementary, railroads constantly seek redundancy.  Observation cars helped to increase passenger train travel popularity as an additional means of enhancing the journey. They were almost universally located at the end of the train to make the trip more enjoyable and usually featured a lounge area and/or sleeping compartments although some cars were also used as diners. Later during the streamliner era designs, such as those used aboard the California Zephyr, featured domed observations for a maximum viewing and sightseeing experience.  Other trains may have been more luxurious and for the well-to-do but none could compare to what the California Zephyr offered in the way of friendly service and breathtaking scenery.  

Seen here is one of the Seaboard Coast Line's tavern-observations (manufactured by Budd in 1947 for the Seaboard Air Line) attached to train #57, the "Silver Meteor," on March 13, 1971. Roger Puta photo.

Operated jointly by the Chicago, Burlington & Quincy (the Burlington Route), Denver & Rio Grande Western, and Western Pacific the train traveled through some of the most spectacular scenery in the country and it was not surprising that it continued to do well even when train travel by the 1960s and 1970s was waning with the public. The train would eventually be operated only by the Rio Grande (which was then renamed as the Rio Grande Zephyr) and after it relinquished the train to Amtrak in the 1980s it was not only retained but also returned to its original name and today the CZ remains one of the most popular long distance trains in the country.  Some railroads chose to design or build their own observation cars, most notable was the Chicago, Milwaukee, St. Paul & Pacific (the Milwaukee Road). When the CMStP&P introduced the regional streamliner, Twin Cities Hiawatha, in 1935 the train operated a unique "Beaver Tail" observation, which featured a sloped rear end thus giving the car its unique name.

A Chicago, Burlington & Quincy company photo featuring the afternoon lineup in Chicago to the Twin Cities during the 1950s. From left to right: a Northern Pacific 390-series sleeper-buffet/lounge-observation (1 compartment/4 bedroom) with the "North Coast Limited"; Great Northern roomette-observation "Grand Coulee" with the "Empire Builder"; and Burlington Vista Dome-parlor-observation "Silver Terrace" with the "Afternoon Zephyr."

Then, a decade later in 1947 when the railroad introduced the transcontinental Olympian Hiawatha the train featured perhaps the most exotic observation car ever built, the famed Sky Tops. Configured as sleeper-lounge cars the Sky Tops were designed by industrial designer Brooks Stevens with the rear of the cars featuring a beautiful solarium lounge that afforded passengers unprecedented views of the outside world.  Domed observation cars were mostly featured on passenger trains of the western railroads due not only to the wide open vistas afforded but also because height restrictions were not such an issue as they were back east, making dome cars in general rather rare (although railroads like the Baltimore & Ohio made use of them the best the could by reducing the height of the domes).

Through the 1930's the open platform observation was used, as seen here on a former Southern Railway car in service on the Algoma Central in November, 1978 (named the "Michipicoten"). Despite a traveler's ability to enjoy the outdoor views, while in motion the platform was windy, noisy, and dusty. Roger Puta photo.

With passenger rail travel waning in the 1960s railroads began to cut back on the service where and when they could. As a result, save for a railroad's most prominent passenger train(s), most runs that operated observation cars lost the service to curb operating expenses. Until the end, however, when Amtrak took over intercity passenger rail operations in the spring of 1971 some railroads remained determined to provide top quality service on their trains such as the Rio Grande's then Rio Grande Zephyr, the Southern Railway, and the Baltimore & Ohio.  With the startup of Amtrak the carrier continued to use observation cars in a limited capacity on some its trains.

Western Pacific's final westbound "California Zephyr," train #17, stops at Portola, California on March 22, 1970. Nearest the photographer is dome-buffet-lounge observation "Silver Crescent" (#881). Doug Wornom photo.

However, the company would eventually park all of its handed down observation cars and removed them from service altogether.  In general and perhaps the easiest way to ride aboard a true observation car today, either a heavyweight or streamlined version, one must find a tourist railroad that operates such a car like the Western Maryland Scenic Railroad, Strasburg Railroad, or Napa Valley Wine Train.  Additionally, however, there is Pullman Rail Journeys which has brought back full Pullman services in 2013 to select Amtrak trains.  Among the amenities offered are observations, diners, and a full staff. 

A pair of Southern Pacific F7A's and GP9 #3318 lead a westbound freight past the old freight office on the Milpitas line at San Jose, California in June, 1970. Drew Jacksich photo.

For more reading about observations the book American Passenger Train Equipment: 1940s-1980s by author Patrick Dorin provides a very nice general history of classic car types used in service (predominantly during the streamlined era) featuring many drawings and detailed information on several.  Also, the book The Cars of Pullman from author Joe Welsh, Bill Howes, and Kevin Holland. As the title implies the book details and highlights the various types of cars Pullman built throughout the years, along with giving a general history of the company in the process.

  1. Home
  2.  ›
  3. Passenger Cars
  4.  ›
  5. Observation

Header Photo: Drew Jacksich

Researching Rights-Of-Way

A popular pastime for many is studying and/or exploring abandoned rights-of-way.  Today, there are tens of thousands of miles scattered throughout the country.  Many were pulled up in the 1970's and 1980's although others were removed long before that.  If you are researching active or abandoned corridors you might want to check out the United States Geological Survey's (USGS) Historical Topographic Map Explorer.  It is an excellent resource with thousands of historic maps on file throughout the country.  Just type in a town or city and click on the timeline of maps at the bottom of the page!

Studying Diesels

You will be hard pressed at finding a better online resource regarding diesel locomotives than Craig Rutherford's TheDieselShop.us.  The website contains everything from historic (fallen flags) to contemporary (Class I's, regionals, short lines, and even some museums/tourist lines) rosters, locomotive production information, technical data, all notable models cataloged by the five major builders (American Locomotive, Electro-Motive, General Electric, Fairbanks-Morse, and Baldwin), and much more.  A highly recommended database!

Electro-Motive Database

In 1998 a gentleman by the name of Andre Kristopans put together a web page highlighting virtually every unit every out-shopped by General Motors' Electro-Motive Division.  Alas, in 2013 the site closed by thankfully Don Strack rescued the data and transferred it over to his UtahRails.net site (another fine resource).  If you are researching anything EMD related please visit this page first.  The information includes original numbers, serials, and order numbers.