1. Home
  2.  ›
  3. Locomotives
  4.  ›
  5. Triplex

"Triplex" Steam Locomotive: Specs, History, Photos

Last revised: February 22, 2025

By: Adam Burns

Throughout the era of steam locomotive technology, particularly during the 20th century, there were many interesting and unique concepts that were tested such as the 2-10-10-2, steam turbine, Pennsylvania Railroad's marginally successful Duplex Drives, and numerous others. 

The Triplex locomotive can certainly be added to this list, which was originally patented by a Baldwin engineer just prior to World War I who believed it would offer incredible tractive effort in slow, drag service. 

The Erie Railroad grew interested in the design since it was looking for a new steamer to tackle the stiff grades along its main line in south-central New York. 

Unfortunately, the locomotive was plagued by design flaws and never proved as successful as envisioned.  Just two railroads tested the Triplex, including the Virginian, with the Rio Grande also contemplating a never-built model.  Before 1930 all Triplexes had been retired.

Photos

Folks gather around Erie Railroad 2-8-8-8-2 "Triplex" #5014 at the yard in Binghamton, New York circa 1914. The locomotive was built by Baldwin in 1914 and named the "Matt H. Shay," an engineer on the Erie.

History

The Triplex steam locomotive was originally designed by the Baldwin Locomotive Works' George R. Henderson in 1914, who believed that a steamer containing an extra set of drivers (three) would offer maximum tractive effort in moving heavy, slow freights over stiff grades. 

According to SteamLocomotive.com what Henderson conceived was a Mallet-type and saddletank-like, articulated design. 

As the site goes on to state, the three sets of drivers worked whereby the middle, high-pressure cylinders exhausted into equal-sized front and rear, low-pressure cylinders. 

The extra set of drivers made for a very unique design; since the Triplex used a standard boiler and tender, the only area in which the last set could be placed was straddling the cab and under the tender with just enough room to place a trailing axle.

Erie Railroad

At the time of its development the Erie Railroad was eyeing a more powerful locomotive to tackle the stiff grades of its main line around Gulf Summit, New York, near the Pennsylvania border and less than 30 miles east of Binghamton. 

While the first Mallets were introduced in the United States in 1904 many of the massive, high-horsepower designs (standard or otherwise) like the Challengers, Berkshires, Northerns, and Yellowstones were still a few years away when the Triplex was conceived. 

Data and Specifications

Railroad
Erie Railroad
Class
P-1
Builder
Baldwin Locomotive Works
Year Built
1914
Wheel Arrangement
2-8-8-8-2
Road Numbers
5014-5016
Class
P-1
Engine Wheelbase
71 ½ Feet
Overall Wheelbase (Engine + Tender)
91 Feet
Axle Loading
70,100 Lbs
Weight On Drivers
761,600 Lbs
Engine Weight
853,050 Lbs
Tender Weight (Loaded
316,700 Lbs
Total Engine + Tender Weight
1,169,750 Lbs
Tender Capacity
11,600 Gallons
Tender Fuel Capacity
16 Tons (Coal)
Driver Diameter
63"
Boiler Pressure
210 psi
High Pressure Cylinders
36" x 32"
Low Pressure Cylinders
36" x 32"
Tractive Effort
176,256 Lbs

Had they been developed earlier, this unique locomotive probably would never have been built.  In any event, the Erie received its first Triplex in 1914 listed as Class P-1, numbered 2603 (and named the Matt H. Shay by the railroad, who was an engineer on the Erie), and designed with a 2-8-8-8-2 wheel arrangement.  The steamer offered a mesmerizing level of tractive effort for the time that was greater than 176,000 pounds.

Virginian Railway's interesting 2-8-8-8-4 "Tripex" #700 seen here circa 1916 (manufactured by Baldwin).

Unfortunately, the Erie quickly noticed the Triplex had several issues while in service and surely would not be able to move 600+ car freight trains as Baldwin had predicted:

  • Firstly, the locomotive literally exhausted all of its steam in a short amount of time if operated at speeds greater than 10 mph. 
  • Secondly, since the last set of drivers was under the tender the unit's factor of adhesion was slowly reduced as the coal and water was consumed. 

Finally, the locomotive produced so much tractive effort the drawbars, couplers, and freight car frames of the era could not withstand the prodigious levels of strain being asked of them. 

As a result the Erie was forced to use its Triplexes in helper service only (pushers).  The railroad went on to acquire two other 2-8-8-8-2s from Baldwin; originally numbered 2604-2605 between 1914 and 1916 although all three locomotives were later renumbered to 5014-5016. 

As helpers the Triplexes operated reasonably well on the Erie over Gulf Summit and Susquehanna Hill.  Once the railroad began acquiring its new Class S 2-8-4 Berkshires from Alco and Lima in 1927 the unique Triplexes were retired from service.

Virginian Railway

After the Erie began testing the design in 1914 the Virginian became interested as well.  This railroad operated in southern Virginia and southern West Virginia moving significant volumes of coal from tipple to tidewater. 

Naturally, such a powerful locomotive that offered serious tractive effort would work quite well moving heavy coal trains along the Virginian main line. 

In 1916 it took delivery from Baldwin of the only 2-8-8-8-4 Triplex steam locomotive ever built, listed as Class XA by the railroad (for eXperimental) and given number 700.

Unfortunately, the Virginian had even less success with their single unit, which experienced many of the same problems as the Erie's.  It was designed to operate at 10 mph in drag service but was only able to sustain 5 mph without losing steam. 

Baldwin actually had personnel on hand while the #700 was in service to work out the kinks but they had little success in doing so.  It is said that the unit was not even as reliable as the Erie's three examples and was rather disliked on the Virginian. 

After a short service life the Class XA was returned to Baldwin in September, 1921 and rebuilt into a 2-8-8-0 (Class AF) to operate on the Virginian's Elmore-Clark's Gap main line (12 miles) with a ruling grade of 2.07%.  It carried this arrangement until 1942 when it was again rebuilt as a 2-8-8-2 until 1953.

.  Of note was a designed, but never built, 2-8-8-8-2 that would have operated on the Denver & Rio Grande Western.  Following the Erie's problems the D&RGW lost interest and the locomotive was never built.  

Erie Railroad 2-8-8-8-2 "Triplex" #5016.

Recent Articles

  1. Railroads In The 1870s: Panic, Strike, Mileage, Steel & Air Brakes

    Sep 06, 26 08:44 AM

    3677126452634728289900978.jpg
    U.S. railroads 1870–1880—52,922 to ~93,200 miles. Panic of 1873, Crédit Mobilier, Granger laws, Westinghouse automatic brake 1872, Ashtabula 1876, Great Strike 1877. Decade frame, not the West encyclo…

    Read More

  2. Arizona Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 06, 26 08:29 AM

    verdecanyon-magicalxmas.jpg
    2026 Arizona Christmas trains—Verde Canyon Magical Christmas Journey in Clarkdale, Nov. 27–Dec. 24, one hour, from $60/$40. Polar is Grand Canyon Railway in Williams.

    Read More

  3. Wisconsin Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 06, 26 12:37 AM

    wisconsingreatnorthern-pizza-train.jpg
    2026 Wisconsin Christmas trains—Mid-Continent Santa Express Nov. 28–Dec. 6, East Troy Christmas trolleys Nov. 27–Dec. 20. Polar is Green Bay (sold out).

    Read More

  4. Railroads In The 1860s: Civil War, Pacific Railroad, Mileage & Steel

    Sep 06, 26 12:32 AM

    6i990199273615t1fbnkkkko6010981.jpg
    U.S. railroads 1860–1870—~30,600 to 52,922 miles. Civil War as the decade’s center, Pacific Railway Acts and Promontory, Vanderbilt’s NYC, Pullman Pioneer, Bessemer rail, Westinghouse 1869. Decade fra…

    Read More

  5. Railroads In The 1850s: Mileage, Land Grants, Trunk Lines & the West

    Sep 06, 26 12:20 AM

    850201817y97003822y777910.jpg
    U.S. railroads 1850–1860—9,021 to ~30,600 miles, Illinois Central land grant, NYC 1853, Erie to Dunkirk, PRR/B&O to the Ohio, Minot’s 1851 train order, Rock Island bridge. Facts and lithographs. N…

    Read More

  6. Highball: Railroad Ball Signals, Slang & Meaning

    Sep 05, 26 09:27 PM

    1816235126731950658787987.jpg
    Highball in railroading—ball signals (ball at the masthead meant proceed), Whitefield N.H. survivor, radio and hand-signal slang.

    Read More

  7. CB&Q 4-6-4 3001: History, Specs & Ottumwa Display

    Sep 05, 26 09:14 PM

    cbq-3001-rbc.jpg
    Chicago, Burlington & Quincy class S-4 Hudson 3001—Baldwin 1930, c/n 61446. Fast passenger 4-6-4, August 31, 1958 Barstow fan trip, donated to Ottumwa 1959. Complete specifications.

    Read More

  8. Railroads In The 1800s (1840s): History, Photos, Timeline

    Sep 05, 26 11:29 AM

    6779192031024716554152661829982090988927.jpg
    U.S. railroads 1840–1850—2,808 to 9,021 miles, T-rail and wooden ties, Pennsylvania Railroad charter 1846, 4-4-0 American type, Morse telegraph on the B&O. Facts and photos. Not the whole 19th century…

    Read More

  9. New York Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 05, 26 11:24 AM

    delawawreulster-christmas.jpg
    2026 New York Christmas trains—Arcade & Attica North Pole Express, Adirondack Christmas Train and Thendara Santa Train, Delaware & Ulster Santa’s Silver Sleigh. Polar is Medina, North Fork, Ut…

    Read More

  10. Railroads In The 1820s/1830s: Firsts, Mileage & Founding Era

    Sep 05, 26 10:54 AM

    2868098871j1680187y208011.jpg
    U.S. railroads 1820s–1830s—Granite Railway 1826, B&O common carrier, Stourbridge Lion, Tom Thumb, Best Friend, 2,808 miles by 1840. Firsts, facts, photos.

    Read More

  11. Railroad History (USA): Timeline, Facts & How the Network Was Built

    Sep 05, 26 12:50 AM

    929385273527728732893689260927.jpg
    Full U.S. railroad history hub—origins and inventors, Golden Age peak mileage, Civil War and transcontinental, streamliners, ICC regulation, Penn Central and Conrail, Staggers Act, PSR, and today’s Cl…

    Read More

  12. Grif Teller: Biography, PRR Calendar Art & Legacy

    Sep 05, 26 12:39 AM

    912748127478238925809236.jpg
    Griffith Harold “Grif” Teller (1899–1993)—Osborne Company artist who painted 27 of 33 Pennsylvania Railroad wall calendars, 1928–42 and 1947–58. Biography, titles, four paintings.

    Read More

  13. O. Winston Link: Biography, N&W Night Photos & Sound Recordings

    Sep 05, 26 12:21 AM

    197234162468125791295772985680926778.jpg
    O. Winston Link (1914–2001)—Brooklyn engineer-photographer who documented Norfolk & Western’s last steam, 1955–60, at night, with sound. Hotshot Eastbound, LPs, Roanoke museum. Biography.

    Read More

  14. Poughkeepsie Bridge: Railroad History, 1974 Fire & Walkway

    Sep 05, 26 12:04 AM

    684839203752243304436488.jpg
    Poughkeepsie-Highland Railroad Bridge—first train Dec. 29, 1888, Maybrook freight gateway, May 8, 1974 fire, Walkway Over the Hudson Oct. 3, 2009. Not a New England landmark. Specs, photos.

    Read More

  15. C&O/Chessie 18742: Huntington's Battery Shop Switcher

    Sep 04, 26 11:20 PM

    chessie-switcher-rk.jpg
    C&O/Chessie/CSX 18742: GE 1917 15-ton battery shop switcher at Huntington, W.Va. One locomotive, not a fleet. Newport News E-6, X-5000, Chessie paint.

    Read More

  16. Central New England Railway: Map, Poughkeepsie Bridge Route & History

    Sep 04, 26 10:43 PM

    187241724152612578219869867.jpg
    Central New England Railway—Connecticut Western, Hartford & Connecticut Western, Poughkeepsie Bridge, Reading’s PR&NE, New Haven control 1904, merger 1927. Map, 1891 timetable, what still runs.

    Read More

  17. The Erie War (1868): Vanderbilt, Gould, Drew & Fisk

    Sep 04, 26 10:26 PM

    erie-1868-1.jpg
    The Erie War of 1868—Cornelius Vanderbilt vs. Daniel Drew, Jay Gould, and Jim Fisk for the Erie Railway. Convertible bonds, Jersey City, Albany bribery, July 1868 settlement. Not Black Friday.

    Read More

  18. New York & New England Railroad: Map, Ghost Train, History

    Sep 04, 26 05:33 PM

    1282186356235782968529003788.jpg
    New York & New England Railroad—Boston, Hartford & Erie, inland Boston–Hudson main, Beacon car float, White Train / Ghost Train, 1893 bankruptcy, New Haven lease 1898. Map and 1893 timetables.

    Read More

  19. Railroad Glossary: Terms, Slang, Definitions & Meanings

    Sep 04, 26 05:17 PM

    7002934823746125427375uy2862097089.jpg
    American railroad glossary—highball, FRED, Class I, trackage rights, and operations slang—plus a directory of specialized glossaries and term articles on American-Rails.com.

    Read More

  20. Indiana Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 04, 26 05:08 PM

    hesston-xmas-steam.jpg
    2026 Indiana Christmas trains—Nickel Plate Express Reindeer Express in Noblesville (from Nov. 14). Whitewater Valley is not running due to severe flooding.

    Read More

  21. Georgia Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 04, 26 02:26 PM

    smchristmas-hero.jpg
    This article highlights those organizations offering Christmas-themed train rides in Georgia.

    Read More

  22. Illinois Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 04, 26 02:14 PM

    foxriver-christmas.jpg
    2026 Illinois Christmas trains—IRM Happy Holiday Railway in Union (Nov. 27–Dec. 21) and Fox River Santa’s Trolley Express in South Elgin. Polar is Monticello.

    Read More

  23. 4-8-4 "Northern" Steam Locomotives: History & Survivors

    Sep 04, 26 01:54 PM

    296091237262jn9927801708.jpg
    4-8-4 Northern history—Northern Pacific’s 1926 Class A, Super Power dual-service steam, railroad nicknames, surviving U.S. examples, and which Northerns still run in 2026.

    Read More

  24. Railroad Stations & Depots: History, Architecture & Famous Terminals

    Sep 04, 26 10:29 AM

    679198412734623566893479090.jpg
    American railroad stations—depot vs terminal, B&O’s 1830 Ellicott City, ~80,000 buildings at peak, Penn Station’s 1963 demolition, Grand Central saved. Directory of famous terminals on American-Ra…

    Read More

  25. Colorado Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 04, 26 10:07 AM

    royalgorge-xmas.jpg
    2026 Colorado Christmas trains—Georgetown Loop Santa’s Rocky Mountain Adventure and Lighted Forest (Nov. 6–Dec. 24), Royal Gorge Santa Express (Nov. 19–Dec. 30). Polar is Durango and Golden.

    Read More

  26. Railroads By State: History, Maps & Firsts

    Sep 04, 26 09:53 AM

    600001o231253512t1g1jj1i90620078.jpg
    All 50 U.S. state railroad histories—firsts, 1916 peak of 254,037 miles, today’s ~140,000-mile freight network. Directory of state guides from Alabama to Wyoming.

    Read More

  27. Logging Railroads In The USA: History, States & Last Lines

    Sep 04, 26 09:25 AM

    fordshaydrk.jpg
    American logging railroads—private woods roads and tap lines, Shay/Climax/Heisler, last U.S. line (Simpson 2015), last in North America (Englewood 2017). State guides as they are written.

    Read More

  28. Chicago, West Pullman & Southern Railroad: History & Diesel Roster

    Sep 03, 26 11:46 PM

    cwp-42-bernard-joliet-19730830.jpg
    CWP&S, International Harvester’s South Side switching road between Wisconsin Steel and the West Pullman plants. Complete diesel roster, known steam, 1900–1996. Became Chicago Rail Link.

    Read More

  29. Washington Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 03, 26 11:28 PM

    nrm-christmas-trains.jpg
    2026 Washington Christmas trains—Mt. Rainier Christmas with the Clauses in Elbe (Nov. 21–Dec. 23), plus Snoqualmie Santa Train and Chelatchie Prairie tree trains. Polar is Chehalis.

    Read More

  30. Utah Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 03, 26 11:26 PM

    hebervalley-xmas.jpg
    2026 Utah Christmas trains—Heber Valley Railroad North Pole Express in Heber City, Nov. 19–Dec. 30, ~90 minutes. Coach from $70 adult. Not Polar Express.

    Read More

  31. Tennessee Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 03, 26 11:25 PM

    tvrm-710-hero-christmas.jpg
    2026 Tennessee Christmas trains—TVRM North Pole Limited in Chattanooga, TCRM Santa Express in Nashville, Three Rivers Rambler Christmas Lantern Express in Knoxville. Not Polar Express.

    Read More

  32. Nevada Chirstmas Train Rides: A Complete Guide

    Sep 03, 26 11:24 PM

    nvnorthern-christmas-hero.jpg
    Nevada is historically important as part of the western leg of the Transcontinental Railroad. Today, a handful of museums and heritage railroads can be found in the state and a few host Christmas-them…

    Read More

  33. Railroad Museums In The USA (2026): State Guides & Collections

    Sep 03, 26 10:25 PM

    92039472651243141gj1y86097989.jpg
    U.S. railroad museums—what they are vs tourist railroads, preservation history (R&LHS, NRHS, IRM, Steamtown), state guides, and destination collections. Confirm hours on each museum’s site.

    Read More

  34. Narrow Gauge Railroads (USA): History, Mileage & Lines

    Sep 03, 26 02:39 PM

    23677239926983820862hu874894005090.jpg
    American narrow-gauge railroads—3-foot fever, Hilton’s 11,699 miles in 1885, Denver & Rio Grande, Maine two-footers, survivors you can still ride. History and a growing company list.

    Read More

  35. Railroads In The 1900s (1900–1910): Facts, Statistics, History

    Sep 03, 26 10:05 AM

    44029duytqrxcmtrh35468393764.jpg
    U.S. railroads 1900–1910—ICC miles 193,346 to 240,293, Elkins/Hepburn/Mann-Elkins, interurbans, 20th Century Limited, Penn Station, last transcontinentals. Facts and statistics.

    Read More

  36. Michigan Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 03, 26 12:12 AM

    little-river-xmas.jpg
    2026 Michigan Christmas trains—SRI North Pole Express on Pere Marquette 1225 (Owosso), Coopersville Santa Train, Huckleberry Railroad Holiday Magic, Little River Christmas Express. Not Polar Express.

    Read More

  37. Transcontinental Railroad: Maps, Facts, Completion

    Sep 03, 26 12:12 AM

    dkgh39713579836.jpg
    First transcontinental railroad—Pacific Railway Acts 1862/1864, Central Pacific and Union Pacific, Chinese labor, ten-mile day, Promontory Summit May 10, 1869. Maps, facts, Golden Spike National Histo…

    Read More

  38. PRR B1 Electric Switchers: History, Specs & Roster

    Sep 02, 26 11:41 PM

    prr-b1-hero.jpg
    Pennsylvania Railroad class B1 electric switchers—Altoona/Juniata 0-6-0 (C) boxcabs, 1926–1935. BB1/BB2 pairs, 5684–5697 singles, LIRR B3 sisters, specs, complete roster. 5690 at Strasburg.

    Read More

  39. Florida Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 02, 26 11:17 PM

    frm-northpoleexpress-hero.jpg
    2026 Florida Christmas trains—Florida Railroad Museum North Pole Express in Parrish (Nov. 27–Dec. 22). No licensed Polar Express in Florida. Miami Polar is closed.

    Read More

  40. North Carolina Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 02, 26 01:40 PM

    triangletrain-xmas-hero.jpg
    2026 North Carolina Christmas trains—Tweetsie Christmas (Nov. 27–Dec. 30), Bonsal Santa Express, Aberdeen Carolina Christmas Train. Polar is Bryson City and Spencer.

    Read More

  41. New Orleans & Northeastern Railroad: Map, Route & History

    Sep 02, 26 01:30 PM

    089127317623621452387236983897987.jpg
    New Orleans & Northeastern Railroad—William Hardy, Erlanger capital, 196 miles Meridian–New Orleans, Lake Pontchartrain trestle, Queen & Crescent Route. Southern 1916, AGS 1969, Norfolk Southern t…

    Read More

  42. New Hampshire Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 02, 26 01:25 PM

    granite-xmas-hero.jpg
    2026 New Hampshire Christmas trains—Conway Scenic Santa’s Holiday Express (from Nov. 28, Coach $27/$21) and Lincoln Santa Express. Not Polar Express.

    Read More

  43. Minnesota Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 02, 26 12:18 PM

    mnstreetcar-hero-xmas.jpg
    2026 Minnesota Christmas trains—Duluth Christmas City Express, Friends of the 261 North Pole Express (Dec. 4–13), Minneapolis Holly Trolley. Not Polar Express.

    Read More

  44. Railroad Diamonds: At-Grade Track Crossings, Frogs & Interlockings

    Sep 02, 26 12:00 PM

    6004592575827chwy1678346.jpg
    Railroad diamonds—four frogs where two tracks cross at grade. Rigid, movable-point, and flange-bearing designs, interlocking protection, and why MOW crews hate them.

    Read More

  45. California Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 02, 26 11:58 AM

    nilescanyon-xmas-hero.jpg
    2026 California Christmas trains—Napa Santa Train, Campo North Pole Limited, Niles Canyon Train of Lights, Roaring Camp, Skunk Train, Portola. Polar stays on the Polar hub.

    Read More

  46. Civil War Railroads: North vs South, USMRR, Maps & Facts

    Sep 02, 26 10:32 AM

    8709nchgg5534272839.jpg
    Civil War railroads—1860 mileage, gauges, USMRR, Haupt and McCallum, First Manassas, Gettysburg, Chickamauga, Andrews Raid, B&O. Maps and facts.

    Read More

  47. Milwaukee Road EP-3 "Quills": History, Specs & Roster

    Sep 01, 26 11:49 PM

    0018476157273782628968902709.jpg
    Milwaukee Road class EP-3 Quills—ten Baldwin–Westinghouse 2-C-1+1-C-2 passenger electrics, 1919. Quill drive, Mountain Division Olympian, frame failures, complete roster, all scrapped by 1957.

    Read More

  48. Milwaukee Road's Boxcab Electrics (EP-1/EF-1): History, Specs, Classes

    Sep 01, 26 11:20 PM

    200892347127346235782986800972.jpg
    Milwaukee Road Alco/GE boxcabs—42 pairs, 1915–16, 3,000 V DC. EP-1 and EF-1 through EF-5 and ES-3. Specs, classes, June 1974, E50 Duluth and E57B Harlowton.

    Read More

  49. Milwaukee Road's Vendome Loop: Horseshoe, Grades & Pipestone Approach

    Sep 01, 26 07:28 PM

    30145625296047229esbq5217339.jpg
    Milwaukee Road's Vendome Loop—horseshoe between Vendome and Cedric, Montana, on the 2% east slope of Pipestone Pass. ICC valuation, McIntosh Bros., 1908 track. Not the tunnel.

    Read More

  50. Connecticut Christmas Train Rides (2026): A Complete Guide

    Sep 01, 26 02:31 PM

    rmne-christmas-hero.jpg
    2026 Connecticut Christmas trains—Essex Steam Train North Pole Express (Nov. 20–Dec. 23, Coach from $60), plus Danbury, Naugatuck, Shore Line Trolley.

    Read More

Impact

The Triplex locomotive was a natural progression of steam technology as builders and railroads sought to develop more powerful designs to handle increasingly larger and heavier trains.

Unfortunately, experimental designs like the Triplex, steam turbines, and even Duplexes proved to be relatively unsatisfactory in service.  Nevertheless, they were fascinating concepts aimed at reducing operating costs.

In retrospect, the Triplexes time in service would have been relatively short lived, even had they been successful.  The age of the diesel-electric was just around the corner and Electro-Motive unveiled its FT in 1939.

In addition, Erie had been experimenting with early diesel switchers by the mid-1920s and acquired its first FTs in 1944.  For a railroad constantly plagued with debt and bankruptcy it quickly retired its steam fleet and was fully dieselized by the mid-1950s.