1. Home
  2.  ›
  3. Fallen Flags
  4.  ›
  5. Chesapeake & Ohio
  6.  ›
  7. Advisory Mechanical Committee

Advisory Mechanical Committee (AMC), A Van Sweringens' Group

Last revised: September 9, 2024

By: Adam Burns

The Advisory Mechanical Committee, or AMC for short, was the research and development arm of the Van Sweringen brothers' railroad properties.  

These systems included four principal lines; the Chesapeake & Ohio, Erie, Pere Marquette, and Nickel Plate Road.  

The committee was formed in the late 1920s soon after the brothers had taken control of the railroads and established standardization in Super Power steam designs among them. 

While the Lima Locomotive Works produced several hundred of these locomotives by the 1940s the other majors builders also manufactured them as well.  

Unfortunately, the AMC is not well known since few of their documents survive; a true shame considering the group helped produce some of the best late-era steam locomotives prior to the diesel age.

Oris Paxton  (O.P.) Van Sweringen and Mantis James (M.J.) Van Sweringen were brothers and long-time corporate partners.  

They went through several early business failures before entering the real estate industry around 1909.  Soon after this latest venture they began developing what is now known as the community of Shaker Heights, Ohio, an eastern suburb of Cleveland.

The brothers felt that a high-speed, rapid-transit streetcar operation was essential for the project to ferry commuters to and from their places of work.  

While this system was eventually established the Van Sweringens also wanted to get into the railroad business, purchasing control of the New York, Chicago & St. Louis in 1916, better known as the Nickel Plate Road.

More Reading...

Chesapeake & Ohio, "George Washington's Railroad" 

Pere Marquette Railway, Michigan's Own Road 

Erie Railroad, "Serving The Heart Of Industrial America" 

The Berkshire (2-8-4) Locomotive Type

At the time the NKP was a subsidiary of New York Central and while the rundown property took a bit of time to rehabilitate the Van Sweringens looked to expand their interests in the industry.

By the 1920s they controlled the Erie Railroad, Chesapeake & Ohio, Pere Marquette, and Hocking Valley Railway (the latter two were eventually merged into the C&O).  

While the brothers had no previous railroad experience prior to their Nickel Plate acquisition they did know how to run a successful business.

 According to Thomas Dixon, Jr.'s book, "Chesapeake & Ohio K-4 Class 2-8-4 Steam Locomotives," they brought in experienced railroader John J. Bernet (former Vice President at New York Central) as adviser and operator who officially became president of the Nickel Plate and who oversaw its successful rehabilitation.  

Under his direction a committee was established to oversee the mechanical operations of all the Van Sweringen properties.

This group, established in 1929 and known as the Advisory Mechanical Committee, would offer best practice recommendations and refine steam locomotive designs to best suit each railroad.  

The AMC team was comprised of managers from each railroad's mechanical department and met at the Van Sweringen's headquarters in Cleveland.  

While the group was tasked with generally implementing improvements it is believed they also held a great deal of power in ultimately deciding which new locomotives operated on a particular railroad.

Whether the AMC was also created as a direct result of the Super Power locomotive's birth is unknown (likely only a coincidence) but whatever the case the timing was just right. 

In 1925 New York Central subsidiary Boston & Albany, in conjunction with the Lima Locomotive Works, began testing a new wheel arrangement, the 2-8-4.  

While the locomotive was essentially a Mikado featuring a larger firebox and additional rear axle it proved vastly superior and led to a new design, the Berkshire.  

The "Super Power" concept describes late steam era designs, beginning with the 2-8-4, which featured larger fireboxes and super-heaters.  

The term has also been used to include new technologies being applied at the time such as roller-bearings, mechanical stokers, and outside valve gear.

The first Super Power locomotives used by a Van Sweringen line was the Class S 2-8-4s built for the Erie between 1927 and 1929.  

While the AMC did not influence the refinement of these Berkshires they did base the Chesapeake & Ohio's Class T-1 2-10-4's from them.  Mr. Dixon notes in his book the T-1's were the first examples built with AMC oversight (1929) and they proved incredibly successful on the C&O.  

They typically saw service on the railroad's more rugged western territory often tasked with 160-car coal trains.  In all, forty units arrived from Lima (#3000-3039) and the C&O liked them so well that most of their future Super Power locomotives came from the builder.  

However, because AMC tended to standardize their designs so well any examples outshopped by the major builders (Baldwin, Lima, or the American Locomotive Company) were more or less identical.

The best known AMC design was the standardized 2-8-4 which found its way on all of the Van Sweringen properties.  

However, there were also others including the C&O's Class J-3/a 4-8-4's, its Class L 4-6-4's, and the massive Class H-8 2-6-6-6 "Alleghenies."  

During a 22-year period between 1927 and 1949 Lima manufactured 301 locomotives for the Van Sweringen interests, which Mr. Dixon points out comprised slightly less than half of all the Super Power designs the manufacturer ever produced.  

While Lima was the smallest of the Big Three steam builders its locomotives are often considered some of the best ever built.  Today, one example each of Nickel Plate's and Pere Marquette's 2-8-4's remain operational so it is still possible to see AMC's designs today.

Recent Articles

  1. Alabama's - Wine Tasting - Train Rides

    Jan 10, 26 09:29 AM

    While the state might not be the first to come to mind when one thinks of wine or train travel, the unique concept of wine tasting trains adds a refreshing twist to the Alabama tourism scene.

    Read More

  2. Maryland Dinner Train Rides At WMSR!

    Jan 10, 26 09:13 AM

    53474584775_1617e2c250_k.jpg
    The Western Maryland Scenic Railroad (WMSR) has become one of the Mid-Atlantic’s signature heritage operations—equal parts mountain railroad, living museum, and “special-occasion” night out.

    Read More

  3. Arkansas Dinner Train Rides On The A&M!

    Jan 10, 26 09:11 AM

    54146589389_5b2e0b46a5_k.jpg
    If you want a railroad experience that feels equal parts “working short line” and “time machine,” the Arkansas & Missouri Railroad (A&M) delivers in a way few modern operations can.

    Read More

  4. South Dakota's - Murder Mystery - Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 10, 26 09:08 AM

    44769036_2007471786211415_7062575978807033856_n.jpg
    While the state currently does not offer any murder mystery dinner train rides, the popular "1880 Train" at the Black Hills Central recently hosted these popular trips!

    Read More

  5. Wisconsin's - Murder Mystery - Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 10, 26 09:07 AM

    124981724762157892785298689667.jpg
    Whether you're a fan of mystery novels or simply relish a night of theatrical entertainment, Wisconsin's murder mystery dinner trains promise an unforgettable adventure.

    Read More

  6. Missouri's - Murder Mystery - Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 10, 26 09:05 AM

    12942137552783589268689676.jpg
    Missouri, with its rich history and scenic landscapes, is home to one location hosting these unique excursion experiences.

    Read More

  7. Washington ~ Murder Mystery ~ Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 10, 26 09:04 AM

    912734812478923958785289666.jpg
    This article delves into what makes murder mystery dinner train rides in Washington State such a captivating experience.

    Read More

  8. Kentucky Scenic Train Rides At KRM!

    Jan 09, 26 11:13 PM

    901824214672358729689877.jpg
    Located in the small town of New Haven the Kentucky Railway Museum offers a combination of historic equipment and popular excursions.

    Read More

  9. Washington "Wine Tasting" Train Rides

    Jan 09, 26 08:53 PM

    5983265112_3688b74245_o.jpg
    Here’s a detailed look at where and how to ride, what to expect, and practical tips to make the most of wine tasting by rail in Washington.

    Read More

  10. Kentucky's - Wine Tasting - Train Rides

    Jan 09, 26 08:21 PM

    92834273532578238698389788.jpg
    Kentucky, often celebrated for its rolling pastures, thoroughbred horses, and bourbon legacy, has been cultivating another gem in its storied landscapes; enjoying wine by rail.

    Read More

  11. Kentucky's - Murder Mystery - Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 09, 26 01:12 PM

    49905649598_70c1e624eb_k.jpg
    In the realm of unique travel experiences, Kentucky offers an enchanting twist that entices both locals and tourists alike: murder mystery dinner train rides.

    Read More

  12. Utah's - Murder Mystery - Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 09, 26 01:05 PM

    0182431872456124625782568926897.jpg
    This article highlights the murder mystery dinner trains currently avaliable in the state of Utah!

    Read More

  13. North Carolina Dinner Train Rides At NCTM!

    Jan 09, 26 12:51 PM

    918271264125238956239068978908.jpg
    Tucked into the Piedmont town of Spencer, the North Carolina Transportation Museum is the kind of place that feels less like a typical museum and more like a living rail yard that never quite stopped…

    Read More

  14. Tennessee Dinner Train Rides At The TVRM!

    Jan 09, 26 12:39 PM

    9854sq678o67ytt743.jpg
    Tucked into East Chattanooga, the Tennessee Valley Railroad Museum (TVRM) is less a “museum you walk through” and more a railroad you step aboard.

    Read More

  15. New York Scenic Train Rides On The A&A!

    Jan 09, 26 11:20 AM

    187243712476127521365889238266.jpg
    The A&A is both a common-carrier short line moving freight and a heritage railroad hosting popular excursion trains, all on the same storied right-of-way.

    Read More

  16. Pennsylvania Scenic Train Rides In Hollidaysburg!

    Jan 09, 26 11:14 AM

    54850990279_a6deba6c6f_k.jpg
    Tucked into the Juniata River valley just south of Altoona, the Everett Railroad offers one of the most approachable—and photogenic—heritage-rail experiences in Pennsylvania

    Read More

  17. Montana Dinner Train Rides Near Lewistown!

    Jan 08, 26 03:03 PM

    19287412848213758926777.jpg
    The Charlie Russell Chew Choo turns an ordinary rail trip into an evening event: scenery, storytelling, live entertainment, and a hearty dinner served as the train rumbles across trestles and into a t…

    Read More

  18. Alabama's - Murder Mystery - Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 08, 26 02:19 PM

    27803_AA19794E-6725-11F0-AAB2-4434AD33B17C.png
    There is currently one location in the state offering a murder mystery dinner experience, the Wales West Light Railway!

    Read More

  19. Rhode Island's - Murder Mystery - Dinner Train Rides

    Jan 08, 26 01:43 PM

    Let's dive into the enigmatic world of murder mystery dinner train rides in Rhode Island, where each journey promises excitement, laughter, and a challenge for your inner detective.

    Read More

  20. Florida's - Wine Tasting - Train Rides

    Jan 08, 26 01:13 PM

    231284612783589236.jpg
    Wine by train not only showcases the beauty of Florida's lesser-known regions but also celebrate the growing importance of local wineries and vineyards.

    Read More