Indiana Murder Mystery Train Rides In Noblesville!

Published: December 3, 2025

All aboard for a whodunit on wheels. The Nickel Plate Express, a heritage railroad in Hamilton County, Indiana, has earned a devoted following for themed excursions that blend small-town charm with vintage rail travel.

Among its most sought-after offerings are the murder mystery trains—interactive, laugh-filled capers where passengers become sleuths as the countryside rolls by. If you’re considering tickets or simply curious how these rolling mysteries work, here’s a detailed look at what to expect and how to make the most of the experience.

What is the Nickel Plate Express?

The Nickel Plate Express - also known as the Nickel Plate Heritage Railroad - operates on a historic stretch of rail once served by the famed Nickel Plate Road—formally the New York, Chicago & St. Louis Railroad—part of the region’s 19th-century transportation backbone.

Today, the nonprofit that runs the train focuses on preserving rail heritage and offering community-minded excursions. Most trips operate between Noblesville and the small towns to the north, with departures commonly from Hobbs Station at Forest Park in Noblesville and, on select dates, from the historic depot in Atlanta, Indiana. The route generally runs about 12 miles along the former Nickel Plate. In any event, always check your ticket for your specific departure point.

The appeal goes beyond railfans. Families, couples, friend groups, and team-building cohorts are drawn to themed rides ranging from holiday trains to beer-and-wine excursions. The murder mystery trains, however, combine the romance of the rails with the spontaneity of live theater, creating a one-of-a-kind night out.

What is a murder mystery train like?

Think of it as a cozy, mobile dinner theater. Professional actors—often from established local troupes—play out a scripted caper with room for improvisation and guest interaction. As the train glides through farm fields, creek crossings, and small-town backdrops, you’re served a meal or small plates (depending on the specific event) and invited to keep your eyes and ears peeled for clues.

The actors mingle through the vintage coaches, drop hints and red herrings, and sometimes enlist passengers as minor characters. At the end, everyone submits a guess—and the big reveal brings cheers, groans, and bragging rights.

The tone is typically lighthearted and comedic, not grim. Expect campy characters, clever wordplay, and a few purposely over-the-top moments designed to prompt laughter and conversation among strangers. It’s social by design: the mystery usually plays out across multiple “acts” timed with the ride’s progress, giving you several scenes, interludes, and table-talk moments to compare notes.

The organization also has a unique twist on these popular events by hosting seasonal themed murder mystery rides. In 2025 these will include the "Murder At The Ugly Christmas Sweater Party" and the "Ho Ho Homicide Express."

A Typical Evening On Board

While details vary by production and season, many murder mystery trains follow a rhythm like this:

- Arrival and check-in: Plan to arrive at least 30 minutes early. You’ll check in at the station, get your coach and table assignment, and have time for photos by the locomotive or depot. Parking is typically adjacent to the departure point.
- Boarding and seating: Seating is usually at tables for two to four guests in climate-controlled, vintage coaches. Parties are seated together; larger groups may span adjacent tables. If you’re attending with friends, book together to ensure group seating.
- Departure and Act I: As the train pulls away, the cast sets the stage. You’ll meet the characters, learn the stakes, and witness the first suspicious happenings. Keep an eye on interactions and offhand remarks; throwaway lines can be meaningful.
- Service and sleuthing: Depending on the event, you’ll enjoy a plated dinner, a light meal, or curated bites. There’s often a bar with beer, wine, and soft drinks for purchase. Between scenes, actors circulate to answer questions “in character,” while you and your tablemates dissect alibis and motives.
- Act II and clue gathering: The plot thickens. Expect a twist or two and several carefully placed clues—some obvious, others subtle. Jotting notes on your napkin is not uncommon.
- The reveal and return: As the train heads back to the station, you’ll submit your best guess. The cast then reveals the culprit and ties up loose ends. On some trains, small prizes or recognition go to sharp-eyed sleuths.

Themes, Costumes, and Atmosphere

Part of the fun is that themes rotate. One month might channel a 1920s speakeasy with flapper flair and a bootlegger subplot; another might spoof a high school reunion, a Western saloon, or a glamorous awards gala gone awry.

Guests are usually encouraged—but not required—to dress to theme. Light costuming (think a fedora, pearls, or a feathered headband) can heighten the experience without making it burdensome. The coaches’ vintage ambiance, complete with wide windows and retro detailing, adds visual charm and sets the tone even if you come in everyday attire.

Food and Drink

Menus vary by date. Some murder mystery trains are true dinner trains with multi-course service; others feature hearty appetizers or small plates. The culinary approach typically spotlights local catering partners.

Dietary accommodations might be available with advance notice; if you have restrictions (gluten-free, vegetarian, etc.), reach out before buying tickets to confirm what’s possible. There’s generally a bar onboard with beer, wine, and soft drinks for purchase. In line with railroad policies, outside alcohol is not permitted.

Who Should Go

Couples looking for a memorable date night that’s more interactive than dinner and a movie.

Friend groups and birthday parties who enjoy a themed night out.

Companies seeking casual team-building—nothing like a shared puzzle to get people talking.

Mystery lovers who appreciate live theater and improv comedy.

Age recommendations vary by show; some murder mysteries are adult-oriented in humor and feature a bar, while others are more family-friendly. Check the listing for guidance.

Why It Resonates

The enduring appeal of the Nickel Plate Express murder mystery trains lies in their blend of nostalgia, community, and creativity. You’re not just watching a show; you’re participating in a shared story set against the gentle rhythm of a moving train. The landscape becomes part of the staging, the car’s gentle sway deepens the immersion, and the conviviality of table seating turns strangers into co-conspirators. For locals, it’s a pride-filled celebration of regional heritage; for visitors, it’s a novel way to experience Indiana beyond the usual attractions.

Final Thoughts

Check the Nickel Plate Express website and social channels for current schedules, themes, and menu details. Look for notes about departure location, age guidance, and inclusions. If you have questions about accessibility or dietary needs, reach out before you purchase. Popular dates—especially weekends and holiday-adjacent runs—sell quickly.

In a world of screens and streams, the murder mystery trains offer an analog antidote: live performers, real-time puzzles, and the sensory pleasure of rail travel. Whether you leave with a perfect alibi or a hilariously wrong guess, you’ll step off with a story worth telling—and a few new suspects to side-eye in your photo album.