A Murder Mystery Train Ride In Pennsylvania's Amish Country

Published: October 20, 2025

Steam hisses, a whistle echoes across rolling farmland, and a string of vintage coaches glides past red barns and quilt-patterned cornfields.

That’s the Strasburg Rail Road in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania—America’s oldest continuously operating shortline railroad and one of the country’s most beloved heritage rail experiences.

For generations, Strasburg has offered an unhurried, 45-minute journey through Amish country behind immaculately maintained steam locomotives. In recent years, it has also become known for themed excursions that pair history with hospitality, including an especially popular offering: the "Murder Mystery Train."

Equal parts whodunit and classic supper club, this experience blends theatrical intrigue with a multi-course meal served aboard a moving 19th-century-style train. Here’s a detailed look at the railroad and what to expect when you book the mystery.

Strasburg/Norfolk & Western 4-8-0 #475 is seen here in Strasburg during December of 2019. Jon Wright photo.

A Brief History On Steel Rails

Chartered in 1832 to connect the town of Strasburg with the Philadelphia and Columbia Railroad at Leaman Place, Strasburg Rail Road began life as a practical freight and passenger link for a farming community.

Like many small lines, it weathered boom-and-bust cycles, changing transportation eras, and periods of dormancy. In 1958, a group of local investors rescued the line from abandonment and reimagined it as a living museum that would operate historic equipment in regular service.

They succeeded. Today the railroad runs a fleet of vintage coaches and authentic steam locomotives on its roughly 4.5-mile line between East Strasburg and Paradise, Pennsylvania—9 miles round trip, usually completed in about 45 minutes.

Beyond daytime excursions, Strasburg has grown into a full hospitality and events venue: family-friendly seasonal trains, wine-and-cheese rides, shop tours, special photo charters for enthusiasts, and immersive dinners that turn the rails into a stage. The line also maintains a nationally respected steam shop that restores and services historic equipment for railroads across North America, underscoring Strasburg’s role as both entertainer and preservationist.

Scenery as a supporting character
Even before the first course is served, the landscape steals the show. The route passes tended fields and tidy farmsteads, often with teams of horses working the soil and wash flapping on clotheslines.

The railroad shares the Leaman Place Junction with Amtrak’s "Keystone Corridor," so it’s possible to glimpse modern trains streaking by—a striking contrast to the pace of a steam-hauled evening. Sunsets are particularly beautiful from the train, and the soft golden hour light sets a perfect mood for theatrical intrigue.

The Murder Mystery Train Experience

Strasburg’s Murder Mystery Train is an evening excursion that pairs light refreshments, interactive show performed by professional actors.

The premise changes with the season—sometimes a Gilded Age caper, sometimes a Prohibition-era romp, a harvest-time whodunit, or a yuletide puzzle—but the format is consistent: guests are seated within the railroad's restored first class parlor car #88, and the actors move through the car performing scenes, dropping clues, and engaging passengers in the story. The mystery unfolds between courses and as the train glides along, with the big reveal near the end of the trip.

The theater is playful, light-hearted, and designed for all experience levels—no need to be a mystery buff. Actors roam the aisle as the plot thickens, occasionally “confiding” in guests or asking for a quick opinion. You can be as involved as you like: offer a theory, observe quietly, or simply enjoy the ride. The performances are crafted to be family-friendly unless otherwise noted; some dates may be recommended for adults, especially if cocktails and wry humor are part of the evening’s tone.

Timing, Tickets, and Logistics

Murder mystery trains run on select dates throughout the year, often on weekend evenings and during peak seasons. Because seating is limited and these events are popular, advance reservations are essential. Plan to arrive at the station 30–45 minutes early to check in, get your boarding passes, and settle in; the show effectively begins as soon as you’re seated, and you won’t want to miss an opening clue.

The round trip remains roughly 45 minutes. Parking is available on site. If you want to make a day of it, the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania sits directly across the street and is worth several hours on its own, with an extraordinary collection of locomotives and rolling stock.

Preservation with purpose

Purchasing a ticket supports more than an evening out. Strasburg is both a business and a steward of industrial heritage. Revenue from excursions helps fund ongoing restoration and maintenance of the railroad’s locomotives and cars, as well as skills training for the next generation of craftspeople—machinists, boilermakers, carpenters—who keep steam-era equipment alive. In a country where so much of our industrial past has been scrapped or sanitized, Strasburg’s commitment gives guests a direct line to history you can see, smell, and hear.

Final Thoughts

The railroad's murder mystery experience is a distinctive way to experience one of America’s great heritage railways. You’ll eat well, laugh often, and test your deductive skills—all while rolling through some of the most picturesque farmland in the Northeast behind a living, breathing steam locomotive. Whether you’re a railfan, a theater lover, or simply looking for a memorable night out, it’s an easy recommendation.

Schedules, themes, and menus change seasonally, so check the railroad’s official website for current dates, pricing, age recommendations, accessibility details, and any special instructions for your chosen performance. Then settle in for a classic combination: good company, good food, a touch of mystery, and the timeless romance of rail travel.