Published: November 22, 2026
By: Adam Burns
Patrick Benedict McGinnis was born on May 23, 1904, a Monday, in Palmyra, a town in Wayne County, New York. Current Biography, in the living sketch of 1955, says he was one of four children of Patrick and Ann (Mulgannon) McGinnis, and that his father was a floating gang foreman on the New York Central. He became chairman of the Norfolk Southern, chairman of the Central of Georgia, president of the New Haven, and president of the Boston and Maine. Time, on August 23, 1963, said he had made a million as a Wall Street railroad securities specialist before he went from rating railroads to running them.
The yearbook calls him an authority on railroad bonds from 1930, and on reorganization. Time, on April 26, 1954, says railroaders rated his book the best in the field, and calls it Guide to Railroad Reorganization. The yearbook's title is Guide to Railroad Reorganization Securities. In 1947 a group he led took a controlling interest in the Norfolk Southern, and he was elected chairman. On January 16, 1953, a Friday, he was elected chairman of the Central of Georgia and resigned the Norfolk Southern chair, because, the yearbook says, one man could not hold executive offices on two railroads without leave from the Interstate Commerce Commission. Forbes, as the yearbook cites it, says the Commission's report brought him a fine of $5,000 for extravagance in handling the Norfolk Southern's affairs. Time in 1963 tells that exit another way: a federal judge fined the line for selling securities without competitive bidding, and he was tossed out as chairman.
On April 14, 1954, a Wednesday, he elected eleven directors of the New Haven to Frederic C. Dumaine, Jr.'s ten. The yearbook says he was elected president, with John E. Slater as chairman. Time, reporting that meeting in the April 26 issue, says he planned to install himself as president. In the week before the January 30, 1956, issue he quit the $75,000-a-year New Haven job, less than five hours after he had called a report of his leaving absolute baloney, and five hours after the resignation he was president of the Boston and Maine. The Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, on May 25, 1966, a Wednesday, affirmed his conviction for misapplying assets of that railroad in the sale of ten stainless-steel passenger cars. The opinion states the payments he collected, $35,000.
New Haven EP-5 #379 rolls through the New Rochelle, New York interlocking at Cedar Street with what is likely a New Haven-Grand Central Terminal commuter train on February 4, 1969. The electric is wearing the railroad's updated "McGinnis" livery that McGinnis began applying to equipment during his tenure. Marty Bernard.
On this page: At a glance · Palmyra · The bond desk · Norfolk Southern · Central of Georgia · The New Haven · Boston and Maine · The ten cars
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Born | May 23, 1904, a Monday, Palmyra, Wayne County, New York. One of four. Patrick and Ann (Mulgannon) McGinnis |
| Family | Lucile Whitney, August 4, 1930, a Monday. Son Patrick Benedict. Daughter Carol Iveagh |
| Norfolk Southern | Chairman and director from 1947. Resigned when he took the Central of Georgia chair, January 16, 1953 |
| Central of Georgia | Chairman from January 16, 1953, a Friday. Time says he withdrew after trouble with the stockholders |
| New Haven | Eleven directors on April 14, 1954, a Wednesday. The yearbook says he was elected president. The salary Time later prints is $75,000 |
| Boston and Maine | Board on April 13, 1955, a Wednesday, 273,237 to 197,142. President in the week before the January 30, 1956, issue, five hours after he left the New Haven |
| The money | Time, August 23, 1963: made a million. New Haven salary $75,000 a year. Yearbook, citing Forbes: a $5,000 fine. The court: $35,000 from the car sale |
The yearbook says that as a child he knew the rail yards in and around Palmyra, where his father worked. He attended Palmyra High School. At St. Lawrence University in Canton he met his expenses by managing a motion-picture theatre. He also managed the varsity football team and, the yearbook says, occasionally tried his hand at amateur theatricals. Forbes of April 1, 1955, as the yearbook quotes it, credits that work with an easy public-speaking delivery. He had meant to become a chemical engineer. He majored in chemistry, and in 1926 he received the bachelor of science with high honors.
On graduation he took a place with a New York brokerage firm, offered by a wealthy St. Lawrence alumnus, and he took postgraduate courses at New York University and at Columbia. On August 4, 1930, a Monday, he married Lucile Whitney. They had a son, Patrick Benedict, and a daughter, Carol Iveagh. The yearbook says his faith was Roman Catholic. He belonged to Alpha Tau Omega, the Princess Anne Country Club in Virginia, and the Seaview Country Club in New Jersey. The 1955 business address was 61 Broadway. The house was 30 Belair Road, Staten Island. Time, in the April 26, 1954, piece, describes a sprawling, century-old mansion on Staten Island, overlooking the harbor, and a ferry commute. Time of January 16, 1956, calls Lucile a decorator and an art connoisseur, and says that since he took the New Haven he had spent more than 350 nights aboard his business car, almost always with her.
In 1930 he became manager of the railroad-bond department of Lehman Brothers. In 1931, the yearbook says, the financial structures of the railroads began to fall apart, Lehman Brothers closed that department, and he was out of a job. For the next six years he was in and out of several investment firms. In 1937 he joined the New York Stock Exchange firm of Pflugfelder, Bampton and Rust, in charge of the rail-bond department. Courses at Brooklyn Law School let him serve as an expert witness in 25 of 36 major railroad reorganizations, including the New Haven, which went into receivership in 1935. He also lectured at the New York Institute of Finance.
In 1938 Pflugfelder, Bampton and Rust issued the first book of the facts he had collected on the 36 Class I railroads then in bankruptcy. During 1943 and 1944 he was a consultant to the Office of Defense Transportation. He became a partner of the firm in 1943. In 1946, after that firm was dissolved, he was senior partner in McGinnis, Bampton and Sellger, which is the yearbook's spelling. McGinnis and Company was organized in 1949. Forbes, in the words the yearbook uses, called him the most exciting railroading personality since Commodore Vanderbilt and old Dan'l Drew. Time says he knew the business from roundhouse to board room.
A group of associates, with him, acquired a controlling interest in the Norfolk Southern. In 1947 he was elected chairman of the board and a director of the railway, and of the Norfolk Southern Bus Corporation. In 1948 he established the McGinnis Industrial Center, a Norfolk corporation. In 1949 he was elected chairman of the John L. Roper Lumber Company and of the Roper Realization Company, both of Norfolk. McGinnis, Bampton and Sellger were the agents for Frederic C. Dumaine, Sr., who in 1948 was elected chairman of the New Haven.
In 1952 the group claimed, in the words the yearbook takes from Time of February 22, 1954, that they had brought the railroad from the brink of bankruptcy to a point where stock dividends were resumed. In January 1952 the Interstate Commerce Commission, on its own motion, ordered an investigation into the management. The yearbook, citing Forbes, says that as a result of the Commission's report he was fined $5,000 for extravagance in handling the road's affairs. His reply, in the yearbook, was that you have to spend money to make money, and that he had put the road on its feet. Time of April 26, 1954, says the Commission had criticized his expense accounts while he was boss of that railroad, and that he argued the heavy expenses paid heavy dividends in new business. The same magazine, on August 23, 1963, says he was tossed out as chairman after a federal judge fined the line for selling securities without competitive bidding.
On January 16, 1953, a Friday, he was elected chairman of the Central of Georgia. He resigned the Norfolk Southern the same stretch of events. The yearbook gives the reason as the federal rule against one man in executive offices on two railroads without the Commission's approval. During the Central of Georgia chairmanship, Forbes, as the yearbook quotes it, says he pulled down operating and transportation rates and boosted freight revenues, and that he never did realize a dividend for the stockholders. Time of April 26, 1954, says he had so much trouble with those stockholders after he won control that he withdrew. Time of August 23, 1963, says he was eased out for highhanding the directors.
Frederic C. Dumaine, Sr., died on May 27, 1951, a Sunday. His son, Frederic C. Dumaine, Jr., succeeded him as president. The yearbook says that under the two Dumaines the railroad was dieselized and new passenger cars were bought. McGinnis had bought into the New Haven in 1948. He became dissatisfied with a modernization that had eaten into operating capital so far that dividends were being declared only on the preferred. In April 1953 he elected four directors of his way of thinking. Early in 1954 he charged, in the account the yearbook takes from Time of April 5, that although the railroad had declared a profit every year since 1949, the profit came from real estate, and that as a carrier it had lost over $4,000,000 under the Dumaines.
The New Haven used cumulative voting. Time of April 26, 1954, explains it: one share counted for 21 votes, and the votes could be spread across a slate of 21 directors or lumped. He concentrated on eleven. Dumaine split his votes among 15 and won ten. The meeting ran 41 and a half hours, with eight recesses, while tellers counted proxies for 96 percent of the stock. The count was 488,939 proxies and eleven directors for McGinnis, and 481,302 proxies and ten directors for Dumaine. Time says some thought the balance was the 23,200 shares of John A. Munro, a stockbroker in Morristown, New Jersey. The yearbook says the McGinnis group owned only about 30 percent of the stock, and that the election of the eleven directors, and his election as president, fell on April 14, 1954, a Wednesday. Time, in the issue of April 26, still has him planning to install himself as president, and Slater, president of American Export Lines, as chairman.
Time calls the railroad a $500 million line, and writes of his ideas for an 1,800-mile line. The yearbook says the main line, New York to Boston, was only about 200 miles, with no continuous freight trackage. He wanted, Time says, to pay the remaining $4 a share of back dividends on the preferred, and then to pay dividends on 525,789 shares of common. He was toying with a low-slung aluminum train something like Spain's Talgo, that might make New York to Boston in fewer than three hours. On June 3, 1954, a Thursday, he told the Greater Boston Chamber of Commerce that within a year and a half the time could be two and a half hours. Time of January 16, 1956, says he had by then ordered three such trains, and that he also proposed a moving conveyor between New York and Boston for less-than-carload freight. He would not take Dumaine's private car. Time quotes him: he would be afraid to, after what happened on the Norfolk. The same piece puts Dumaine's stake at more than $18 million.
On May 6, 1954, a Thursday, the yearbook says, the New Haven withdrew an application Dumaine had filed for commutation-fare increases of 24 to 30 percent. He maintained that the railroad had the density to make passenger service pay. Time of January 16, 1956, says 63 percent of the business came from passengers, and that he treated commuters as a liability. The same piece gives the crowds he inherited as contented a year before: 35,000 suburbanites on the New York end and 22,000 in Boston. By January 1956 the complaints were late trains, sloppy service, and cuts in maintenance. Time says that in 1955 maintenance was curtailed by some $3,000,000. Two weeks later the magazine says commuters protested a slash of $12 million in maintenance funds since 1953. He had the freight cars painted black, white, and Chinese vermilion. Time says Lucile concocted the colors.
The remarks Time prints are tart. Asked about promises after the proxy fight, he said he had given those politicians everything they asked for. Complaints about crowded Friday trains left him unmoved: if everybody wanted to travel on weekends, they would have to stand. Grand stations, he said, were a waste, and a commuter could be just as happy catching the 5:08 in a tent as in the marble of years gone by. A monthly parking charge of $5.50 a car, which he defended in a speech at Norwalk, brought the line about a lousy five bucks and people acting as though he had torn up the tracks. He said he was a businessman, not the Ford Foundation. On July 14, 1955, a Thursday, the yearbook says, the Boston-bound Federal Express left the rails on a sharp curve near Bridgeport. The first eight cars and the locomotive went down a 40-foot embankment. The engineer was killed, and about 24 passengers and crewmen were hurt. He said the accident was not faulty equipment, and that it pointed up the need for the low-center trains he had been advocating. The yearbook takes that sentence from the New York World-Telegram and Sun of that day.
In the week before the January 30, 1956, issue he was 51. Time says he had been in the job 21 months. He roared that a report of his leaving was absolute baloney. Less than five hours later he said he would quit, because a splinter group of directors did not like the way he was running the railroad. Morgan B. Brainard, Sr., of the Aetna Life Insurance Company, had resigned from the board twelve months earlier. The directors tried Werter S. Hackworth, president of the Nashville, Chattanooga and St. Louis. Hackworth's answer, in Time, was too many commuters and too many headaches. The board chose George Alpert, 57, a Boston lawyer, at $50,000 a year. Alpert had helped the 1954 fight. He said he would hire an operating boss, buy a large number of diesels, add $3,000,000 to maintenance in 1956, and run the trains on time. Until the public had proper service, he said, the investors were not entitled to a return.
McGinnis claimed a profit of $9,275,000 for eleven months of 1955, almost double the 1954 net. Two weeks earlier Time had printed an estimate of $10.5 million for 1955. Dumaine, Jr., said they must have lost $7,000,000 running the railroad 20 months, using cash reserves and income from subsidiaries such as The Connecticut Company. Time says long-term debt rose from $193,850,000 to $199,580,000. A footnote in that issue says he used New Haven cash to pay preferred dividends, of which he held little, so that he could pay the common, of which he and the directors held 128,500 shares. The common, Time says, skidded from a high of 39 to a low of 28 in 1955.
He wanted the Boston and Maine while he still had the New Haven. In December 1954, the yearbook says, three of his friends had acquired the largest single block of that stock. On March 7, 1955, a Monday, the Commission, alerted by New England senators including Leverett Saltonstall and John Kennedy, announced an inquiry into purchases by interests under the control of, or friendly to, the New Haven management. The yearbook cites the New York Times of the next day. At the annual meeting of April 13, 1955, a Wednesday, the slate favorable to him received 273,237 votes to 197,142. Time of April 25 says Edward S. French, the chairman, and Timothy G. Sughrue, the president, resigned before the proxies were counted, afraid that if they stayed and were fired they would lose their pensions. The yearbook spells the president Timothy J. Sughrue, and says the two men had resigned the day before the meeting.
The victory, Time says, gave him and his friends control of a road with 3,200 miles of track and a 1954 operating profit of $3,987,721, and, with the New Haven, 80 percent of the railroad business in New England. In the January 30, 1956, issue the same magazine calls the Boston and Maine a small 1,575-mile railroad that ran its trains on time. In his corner, Time says, were Burton M. Cross, a former governor of Maine, Francis P. Murphy, a onetime governor of New Hampshire, and Pierre Dumaine, called Spike, a brother of Frederic Dumaine, Jr. Spike was named a director.
He was not yet president of both roads. Time of April 25, 1955, says he expected the new board to name him president, and that no one at the Commission could remember the agency letting one man be chief executive of two major roads. A preliminary opinion, the magazine says, held that the group was already violating the act that forbids one railroad to take control of another without permission. The yearbook says the new board authorized counsel to seek that authority, set up an interim executive committee of six, and elected Lloyd J. Kiernan executive vice-president. At a Commission hearing on April 18, 1955, a Monday, it came out that he himself held no Boston and Maine stock, and that a sizeable block had been bought for his wife. The presidency Time dates is the week before January 30, 1956: five hours after he quit the New Haven, he became president of the Boston and Maine.
He left the chair of that railroad in 1962. Time of August 23, 1963, says he resigned as chairman the year before, and gave health as the reason. By the week of that issue the president was Daniel A. Benson. The magazine says a Boston federal grand jury had just indicted McGinnis, Benson, vice-president George F. Glacy, and a broker, Henry Mersey, over kickbacks in the sale of surplus cars. He denied the charges from a Manhattan office, where he was then vice-president of Highway Trailer Industries Inc.
The indictment Time reports, and the conviction the Court of Appeals affirmed, are the same sale, told at two dates. Time, in August 1963, gives the charge: in 1958 another broker offered $500,000 for ten passenger and baggage cars, McGinnis blocked that sale, the railroad sold the cars to Mersey for $250,000, Mersey resold them for $425,000, and the indictment said Mersey gave McGinnis $35,000, Benson $11,500, and Glacy $25,000. Mersey's office, the magazine says, was in the same building as the railroad's.
The opinion is Glacy v. United States, with McGinnis, Benson, and Mersey, 361 F.2d 31, decided May 25, 1966, a Wednesday, after argument on May 3. Chief Judge Aldrich wrote for the court. At the time of the sale, the opinion says, McGinnis was president, Glacy was vice-president for finance and accounting, and Benson was vice-president for operations. They were convicted of misapplying assets of the railroad, under 18 U.S.C. 660. Mersey and the International Railway Equipment Corporation, of which he was sole stockholder, were convicted of aiding and abetting. Count 1, a Clayton Act count, had gone to the Supreme Court as United States v. Boston and Maine Railroad, 380 U.S. 157 (1965), and was dismissed during the trial. The convictions the court affirmed were on Count 2.
The government's evidence, as the opinion recites it, was that the officers put before the directors a sale of ten stainless-steel passenger cars for $250,000, an unreasonably low price, and won approval by false statements of what similar cars were selling for. The cars went to Mersey. The railroad was paid only after Mersey had sold them to another road already committed to buy at $425,000. Mersey then paid the three officers $35,000, $25,000, and $11,500, a total of $71,500. On April 30, 1958, a Wednesday, a dealer named Bugbee asked Glacy for an option at $500,000. Glacy refused. The directors voted the sale on July 23, 1958, a Wednesday. It was consummated on August 14, a Thursday. The memorandum for the board did not name the buyer. It said the sale was recommended by management. The opinion says both omissions were contrary to practice.
McGinnis collected three checks from Mersey: two on October 10, each for $10,000, and one on December 3 for $15,000. On the stand he said the money was for work on a loan, called the Schiavone loan, that never went through. In January 1962 he had told an investigator for the Commission that he had never received any payments from Mersey or the company, and specifically that he had not received $35,000. The opinion says there were further inconsistencies in the explanations he gave in court. The court affirmed. The opinion does not state the months of a sentence, or a fine.
Nov 22, 26 12:04 AM
Nov 21, 26 11:35 PM
Nov 21, 26 11:31 PM
Nov 21, 26 10:27 PM
Nov 21, 26 10:18 PM
Nov 21, 26 09:47 PM
Nov 21, 26 06:37 PM
Nov 21, 26 01:34 PM
Nov 21, 26 01:22 PM
Nov 21, 26 11:01 AM
Nov 21, 26 12:33 AM
Nov 21, 26 12:22 AM
Nov 21, 26 12:13 AM
Nov 20, 26 10:27 PM
Nov 20, 26 10:00 PM
Nov 20, 26 11:50 AM
Nov 20, 26 10:08 AM
Nov 20, 26 12:25 AM
Nov 20, 26 12:06 AM
Nov 19, 26 11:41 PM
Nov 19, 26 07:03 PM
Nov 19, 26 06:51 PM
Nov 19, 26 06:03 PM
Nov 19, 26 05:39 PM
Nov 19, 26 05:05 PM
Nov 19, 26 04:44 PM
Nov 19, 26 02:47 PM
Nov 19, 26 02:43 PM
Nov 19, 26 02:38 PM
Nov 19, 26 02:28 PM
Nov 19, 26 02:18 PM
Nov 19, 26 01:43 PM
Nov 19, 26 11:53 AM
Nov 19, 26 12:36 AM
Nov 19, 26 12:23 AM
Nov 19, 26 12:18 AM
Nov 18, 26 11:26 PM
Nov 18, 26 10:47 PM
Nov 18, 26 09:19 PM
Nov 18, 26 05:21 PM
Nov 18, 26 12:24 PM
Nov 18, 26 10:22 AM
Nov 17, 26 11:52 PM
Nov 17, 26 10:51 PM
Nov 17, 26 05:03 PM
Nov 17, 26 04:52 PM
Nov 17, 26 04:49 PM
Nov 17, 26 03:30 PM
Nov 17, 26 11:12 AM
Nov 17, 26 10:53 AM